Yeah while he was opinionated and annoying I really don't see him making a mistake like that. I mean the guy seems like the kind of person who regularly talks about this stuff; he would have been corrected by now if nothing else.
I would call for a new poll, but I'm very happy with my vote and I think it's hilarious that Seeker (who I love) is the house bitch on our forum. I'm very pleased with the way this turned out.